Police respond to murder site and three other domestic disturbance calls March 10 to 23

Noreen Biehl

Police listed a domestic disturbance call as “report taken” for a call received at 8:44 p.m. March 22, but had no more information in the log about the death of Sherri Sweet at her home on Brattle Street.

Sweet was declared dead of a gunshot wound the next day and her boyfriend, Jeremiah Godfrey, was arrested and charged with murder March 26. (https://southberwickreporter.org/2025/03/30/tragic-brattle-street-shooting-ends-in-death-and-arrest/).

During the period of March 10 to March 23, the South Berwick Police Department logs also reported three other domestic disturbance calls, two listed as unfounded; three arrests; 127 motor vehicle stops; and five accidents.

The log states “peace restored” after a domestic disturbance call on March 17 at 5:11 pm at a York Woods Road residence

Lt. Scott Stephens provided information on the three arrests. A 32-year-old male from South Berwick was arrested on Springtree Lane March 10 at 7:48 p.m. on a charge of violating conditions of release; a 29-year-old male from Dover was charged with “failure to register a vehicle greater than 150 days” on March 13 at 9:54 a.m. during a motor vehicle stop near Portland and Highland streets; and a 56 -year-old male from South Berwick was charged with criminal mischief after a disturbance call from an Old South Road residence on March 22 at 11:25 a.m., Stephens said.

Five accidents were logged during this period with no injuries reported:

  • March 11, 12:36 a.m., on York Woods Road, civil summons issued
  • March 12, 7:17 p.m., near South Berwick House of Pizza on Main Street
  • March 14, 3:56 a.m., near Marshwood High School on Route 236
  • March 14, 5:43 a.m., on Route 236
  • March 14, 4:36 p.m., near Route 236 and Main Street

The following is a summary of logs for March 10 to March 23:

  • Motor vehicle stops: 127 (1 arrest)
  • Directed patrols: 144
  • Medical assists: 22
  • Animal complaints: 10
  • Community police contacts: 10
  • Suspicious activities: 9
  • Found/lost properties: 5
  • Harassment: 5
  • Concealed weapon applicants: 4
  • Domestic disturbances: 4 (2 unfounded, 1 peace restored, 1 report taken)
  • Larcenies: 3
  • Disturbances: 2 (1 arrest)
  • Mental health assists: 2
  • ATV complaint: 1
  • Brush fire: 1
  • Civil complaint: 1
  • Drug incident:1
  • Foot patrol: 1
  • Odor investigation: 1
  • Parking violation: 1
  • Probation/bail/condition check: 1
  • Serve restraining order: 1
  • Serve subpoena: 1
  • Sex offender registration: 1
  • Shoplifting: 1
  • Vandalism: 1
  • Violation Condition of Release: 1
  • Welfare check: 1

FREE weekly news updates from South Berwick Reporter – sign up here.